Case Study

Multivesco
200 Rue Montcalm

Gatineau, Quebec, Canada

11.64

FINANCIAL SAVING

$7,011 (CAD)

CO2 SAVING

110,400 kg

A pilot of EndoTherm was run by Multivesco at 200 Rue Montcalm in Gatineau after recommendation from WSP’s team in Ottawa. This modern, glass fronted Class A office is heated and cooled by a two-pipe heat pump system. This means EndoTherm will provide improvements in heat transfer throughout the heating and cooling season. The product was installed into Tower 1 which takes up 60% of total electrical consumption of the site.

The site is not sub-metered and thus the total consumption includes other electrical loads such as lighting / computers. This baseload (none-HVAC consumption) will be identified as part of the analysis. 60L of EndoTherm was installed into the system in January 2019.

The measurement & verification is based on the ‘International Protocol for the Measurement & Verification of Performance (IPMVP).’ Historical data was supplied by WSP/Multivesco over the past 2 years. This did include some estimated data which was eliminated from consideration. The consumption data was normalized using Heating & Cooling Degree Data from the nearby weather station at Gatineau Airport at a baseload of 18.5°C.

The billing data for April/May and May/June was estimated data. Thus the meter reading taken on the 31st July 2019 suggests that this estimate was on the low end as the value for June – July was higher. If you average these three months there is a saving compared to similar months in previous years.

The final time monthly period runs from the 23rd June – 31st July runs for 38 days. This is seven days more than the rest of the monthly periods and thus the non-electrical baseload will be increased. To reflect this the baseload will be increased from 293,403kWh to 359,655kWh.

The predicted consumption is calculated by inputting the combined HDD+CDD into the line of best fit equation y= 317.7x + 293,403. This is compared with the predicted consumption to calculate the saving during the time period.

Results

From To No. Days HDD CDD HDD+CDD Usage
(kWh)
Data Type Predicted
Usage
(kWh)
Usage
Difference
(kWh)
2019-01-24 2019-02-23 30 901.1 0 901.1 545,400 Actual 579,682.47 34,282.47
2019-02-24 2019-03-25 29 745 0 745 525,600 Actual 530,089.5 4489.5
2019-03-26 2019-04-23 28 446.5 0 446.5 360,000 Actual 435,256.05 75,256.05
2019-04-24 2019-05-23 29 261.7 2 263.7 287,100 Estim 377,180.49 90,080.49
2019-05-24 2019-06-23 30 102.7 29.1 131.8 287,100 Estim 335,275.86 481,75.86
2019-06-23 2019-07-31 38 14.3 171.5 185.8 411,300 Actual 418,683.66 7,383.66
TOTAL   184 2471.3 202.6 2,673.9 2,416,500   2,676,168.03 259,668.03

Savings

Compensated Saving:

11.64%

Total Cash Saving:

$7,011 (CAD)

Total CO2 Saving:

110,400 kg

Over the 6-month pilot period the actual consumption was 259,668kWh lower than the predicted consumption. This is a 9.7% reduction in consumption. It is worth noting that the baseload (293,403kWh) for each month is roughly 50% of the total consumption thus cooling accounts for only 50% of total consumption. This would make the HVAC saving 19.4%. As EndoTherm was only installed into Tower 1 (60%) the saving is therefore 11.64%

This is higher than the average saving achieved by EndoTherm over the past 5 years and can most likely be accounted for by variance in other electrical consumption on site. At 4.5c/kWh this is a saving of $7,011. This also confirms that the product investment has a typical ROI within 1 year.

Each kWh saving is also a reduction of CO2e. The total saving is equivalent to 110,400kg (110.4 metric tonnes) of CO2e.

Contact Us

Permission to contact:

8 + 5 =

International Journal of Energy Management features EndoTherm

EndoTherm is featured in the latest issue of the International Journal of Energy Management (Volume 3, Issue 5, 2021) which is published by the Association of Energy Engineers (AEE)....

Aboriginal Housing Management Association Published Case Study

Who are AHMA? AHMA is an umbrella organization composed of 41 Members that are each Indigenous Housing and Service providers. Our members represent over 5000 Indigenous families living...

EndoTherm is a pre-approved technology under the REC program provided by the MCCAC in Alberta

Who are the MCCAC? The Municipal Climate Change Action Centre (MCCAC) was founded in 2009 as a collaborative initiative of the Alberta Urban Municipalities Association, Rural...

EndoTherm Hydronic Additive Featured in Engineered Systems

The success of EndoTherm seen by Burnaby School District was featured in Engineered Systems Magazine

Impact of COVID-19 on building heating demand and M&V of EndoTherm Performance

COVID-19 has had an unprecedented impact on global behavior including the way we use buildings. With many commercial buildings left unoccupied, domestic demand has significantly increased as people...