Case Study

Wenke Greenhouses

MI, United States

18.1

FINANCIAL SAVING

$6,013.98 (USD)

CO2 SAVING

134,420 lbs

The performance of EndoTherm was piloted by Wenke Greenhouses at 5888 Market Street. EndoTherm was installed in February 2020. The pilot was also part of an initial review of the technology by Consumers Energy / Franklin Energy in Michigan.

A baseline was run using historical data between May 2017 and January 2020 normalised using Heating Degree Days (HDD) from Kalamazoo / Battle Creek Airport in Michigan at a base-load of 65°F. The initial baseline showed a significant increase in consumption during the February – May periods which is in line with the main growing season for the site.

HVAC consumption makes up for about 50% of total gas consumption on site. It is thus expected that
EndoTherm savings will be between 5-8%.

Figure1: Pilot baseline identifying increase consumption during Feb-May which is the main growing period.

Figure 2: EndoTherm analysis compared with the growing season baseline.

As the post-EndoTherm pilot period falls under this growing period the baseline will focus on consumption between February and May.

The three months after EndoTherm was installed was compared to the pre-installation baseline. Each month the known HDD value was input into the trend-line equation (y = 2.2974x + 2845.7) to determine the predicted consumption. The difference between the predicted consumption and the recorded consumption is the recorded saving on site:

Results

Month HDD Predicted Consumption (MCF) Actual Consumption (MCF) Difference (MCF)
March 774 4,623.9 4,358.5 265.4
April 591 4,203.5 3,753.0 450.5
May 273 3,472.9 3,075.0 397.9
Total 12,300.21 1,186.5 1,113.7

 

Savings

Total Saving:

18.1%

Total Cash Saving:

$6,013.98 (USD)

Total CO2e Saving:

134,420 lbs

 

 

Contact Us

Permission to contact:

2 + 3 =

International Journal of Energy Management features EndoTherm

EndoTherm is featured in the latest issue of the International Journal of Energy Management (Volume 3, Issue 5, 2021) which is published by the Association of Energy Engineers (AEE)....

Aboriginal Housing Management Association Published Case Study

Who are AHMA? AHMA is an umbrella organization composed of 41 Members that are each Indigenous Housing and Service providers. Our members represent over 5000 Indigenous families living...

EndoTherm is a pre-approved technology under the REC program provided by the MCCAC in Alberta

Who are the MCCAC? The Municipal Climate Change Action Centre (MCCAC) was founded in 2009 as a collaborative initiative of the Alberta Urban Municipalities Association, Rural...

EndoTherm Hydronic Additive Featured in Engineered Systems

The success of EndoTherm seen by Burnaby School District was featured in Engineered Systems Magazine

Impact of COVID-19 on building heating demand and M&V of EndoTherm Performance

COVID-19 has had an unprecedented impact on global behavior including the way we use buildings. With many commercial buildings left unoccupied, domestic demand has significantly increased as people...